....... HOME .......
MAIN ARTICLE
.... ESSAYS ....
... HISTORY ...
DISCUSSION
.... GALERY ....
. .
........ EDIT ........
Contents

Behavioral Traits Of Living Organisms
....- 1. Growth
....- 2. Reproduction
....- 3. Motion
....- 4. Responsiveness
....- 5. Adaptation
....- 6. Consumption
....- Subordinate Traits
* Exceptions To The Traits Which Define Living Organisms
....- Life-Like Non-Living Entities
....- Seemingly Defective Living Organisms
* Micro-Structure Of Living Organisms
....- The Cell
....- Dna And Rna
....- Complex Proteins
* Essence Of Life
....- Historical Definitions Of Life
....- A Possible Definition Of Life
* Levels Of Life
....- Bios (Life)
....- Anima (Soul)
....- Sentience (Spirit)
....- Hierarchy Of Life
* Origin Of Life
....- The Nature Of The Question
....- The Irreducibility Of Life
....- Rna World
....- Alternate Hypotheses
....- Intelligent Design
Keywords
See Also
References
Bibliography



Life


Fundamental Trait

Newest Version 25 | updated Tue, Sep 3, 2024 at 21:35:29 | 33179 bytes - by Anonymous.
This article is for information and educational purposes only and is not intended to give medical, legal or professional advice..

Life is a fundamental trait which distiguishes living organisms from minerals, fluids and plasmas and is associated with the integration of information and energy by complex structures.

Introduction

Experience teaches us that living things, which include us, as humans, are different in their behavior from other objects that surround us. Their behavior is more complex and in some way less amenable to mathematical description. We are able to identify behavior which is common to all living creature and this allows us to categorize living creatures into a strict category which distinguishes them from non living objects. However, even tough this unique behavior is the result of life, it does not define the essence of life itself. Therefore in order to define life we must first determine what life does, what behavior make it different from non-living objects and then we must look into the structure of living organisms at the most foundational level to try to determine the source of this complex behavior.


Behavioral Traits of Living Organisms

As one examines all living creatures one sees a great diversity in form, structure and behavior. However, all life forms share some common behavioral traits. When on looks at lists of these traits in textbooks it is apparent that the lists vary. The reason is that some traits are related and some lists are more specific and distinguish some traits while other lists combine similar traits. What follows is one possible list of traits which can be used to define living organisms and distinguish them from non-living objects. It is important to note that these are characteristics of living organisms, they tell us what life does. They do not constitute a definition of life.


1. Growth

The size of living organisms changes through time. Almost all living organisms begin their independent existence small and they get bigger with time. As the organism reaches the end of its existence it may have undergo a small reduction in size before it dies and decomposes. In multicellular organisms growth is often accompanied by the reproduction of individual cells even though there might also be growth of individual cells. Consequently, this trait is related to reproduction.


2. Reproduction

Living organisms reproduce, they have offsprings, babies. Some organism produce intermediate forms like seeds and eggs, some produce immature forms like babies and some simple organisms split in half. Reproduction is a form of growth because it causes the growth of the population. Furthermore, growth is generally caused by the reproduction of the smaller parts of the organism. For example, the growth of large plants and animals is caused by the reproduction of small units called cells within the organism.


3. Motion

Living organisms move. Some move faster than others, but even plants move slowly to follow the sun. Sometimes the motion might be microscopic. For example, when nerves are activated, tiny molecular valves open to allow charged molecules in and out of the cells.


4. Responsiveness

Living organisms respond to stimuli. This response almost always involves some form of motion, so it is related to the trait of motion.


5. Adaptation

Living organisms adapt to their environment. They adapt in two different way. (A) There is a fast short-term adaptation by individual organisms. This is seen primarily in some complex living organisms, mostly animals, which adapt as individuals by the process of learning. (B) All kinds of living organisms are able to adapt as a group to their environment by producing offsprings which are slightly different from each other. Therefore, some offsprings will be better suited to certain environments and tasks than others.


6. Consumption

Living organisms eat. In order to accomplish the tasks above they have to absorb chemicals and energy from their environment. Plants absorb nutrients through the roots and energy through their leaves, although some carnivorous plant have specialized leaves capable of capturing and digesting insects. Animals extract both energy and nutrients from their food. Some textbooks call this category metabolism, but that focuses on the use of energy. However, living organisms must also consume chemicals in order to maintain their body structure.


Subordinate Traits

Many lists of traits of living organisms include various internal traits which are found in all living organisms. These are qualities which characterize living things on the inside. These traits can be considered to be subordinate to the other traits. In other words, the things which living things do are so complicated that they need to have structures which are stable and complex. Therefore, in a way, the purpose of these traits is to permit the existence of the external traits. These traits are not as clearly defined as the external traits, and there are several ways to describe the internal characteristics of organisms. In the list below we find one common way to do it. This section describes general internal traits (not components). In the next section will examine more closely specific internal components of living organisms.


(A) Homeostasis (stability and balance) – living things have to maintain a stable environment inside their bodies in order to function properly. For example, they must keep the concentration of salts and minerals within a certain range and the more complex animals must also keep their body temperature close to an ideal temperature. When these conditions vary the organism will experience thirst, fever, hunger or other sensations, and if the environment is not restored to its ideal range the organism will die. Homeostasis is based on the principle of stability and balance. Not too hot, not too cold, not too salty, not too watery, not too acidic, not too basic, etc. In order to maintain homeostasis the different parts (or organs) of the organism must communicate with each other and respond to the other parts. This communication between organs creates feedback loops and regulatory networks which are the basis for homeostasis.


(B) Organization (complexity and hierarchy) – living things are often called organisms because they are composed of smaller parts which are in turn composed of even smaller parts. Since living organisms perform many tasks, these tasks are assigned to specialized units. These units can be arranged into larger units which perform even more complex tasks. For example, animals are composed of organs, which are made up of tissues, which are made of cells, which are divided into compartments (the nucleus, cytoplasmic space and mitochondria) which are similar to the simpler bacterial cells, which contain organelles, which are made up of proteins and other complex molecules. This is based on the principles of complexity and hierarchy.


Exceptions to the Traits Which Define Living Organisms

There are some objects which we consider to be non-living which share some of the traits found in the list above. We could call these life-like non-living entities. Furthermore, some living organisms seem to be missing some of these traits. We could call these seemingly defective living organisms.


Life-like non-living entities

Automobiles – they move and consume gasoline and oil.


Crystals – they grow and consume minerals in solution.


Fire – grows, consumes fuel and reproduces.


Clouds – grow, absorbs energy and humidity from the environment (eats), and reproduce (clouds cause the formation of other clouds).


Computer viruses – they reproduce, move and consume energy and disc space (they eat) and a few even adapt.


However, these examples are not considered to be living organisms for the two following reasons. (A) First of all, these objects do not share all the traits of living organisms. Most living organisms posses all the defining traits listed above. (B) Secondly, living organisms do not just act like they are alive, they are alive. They contain life. The objects listed above might resemble living creatures in some ways but they do not posses life. A later section discusses a formal definition of life.


seemingly defective living organisms

Some living creatures do not posses all of the traits which categorize most living things.


Some plants move very little – For example, large woody trees are basically fixed into a rigid position. However, even trees often have parts which move slowly, like their leaves and seed pods. Also, sap and nutrients move through their internal vascular structure. Furthermore, these trees had more motility when they were young and growing.


Some organisms cannot reproduce – Old and injured animals (like old people, for example) cannot reproduce, and some organisms are born without the ability to reproduce. This is true of unusual crosses like the mule. Mules cannot produce more mules. However, they themselves are the product of reproduction, they are produced by crossing a horse and a donkey. Furthermore, the cells inside these animals are constantly reproducing themselves and that is what keeps these animals alive.


Some organisms can exist in a state of suspended animation where they no longer have to eat – This is true of seeds, for example. However, one could say that seeds are not actually alive in the full sense of the word, but are only potentially alive. They become alive when the seed absorbs water and the tiny plant inside the seed begins to absorb nutrients and energy stored in the seed.


Many animals quit growing when they reach a pre-determined size – However, all these animals had a period of significant growth early in life. Furthermore, even many mature animals can still grow if they over eat, but this growth is unhealthy.


The traits which characterize living organisms are most strongly expressed in young organism. As an organism ages and approaches death the expression of the traits which characterize living organisms begins to diminish.


Micro-Structure of Living Organisms

In order to arrive at a definition of life it is important to look at the components of the simplest examples of living organisms. These simple organisms belong to a category called prokaryotes, which are singled celled organisms which do not contain a nucleus nor other internal membrane bound structures or organelles. Prokaryotes are divided into two groups, bacteria and a related group of organisms called the Archaea. Archaea are most well known as one of the microbes which give some hot springs their brilliant colors. These two groups are structurally very similar and differ mainly in the chemistry of their metabolism and the use of different enzymes in translation and transcription. These differences are not important for the definition of the essence of life.


The Cell

All living organisms are composed of small structures called cells. Prokaryotes also take the form of simple cells. Cells are enclosed in a lipid membrane which is partially impermeable to water, ions, and other molecules. The lipid membrane, because it is basically composed of oil, is completely impermeable to water and to water soluble substances but the membrane contains pores of different types composed of various types of complex proteins which control the entry and exit of water, ions and other molecules. The cell membrane is essential for maintaining a high concentration of essential ions, enzymes and complex proteins within its enclosed space. Without this high concentration of essential components, life would grind to a halt and the components would disperse into nothingness. This concentration of molecules serves as a form of energy storage. Cells convert the concentration gradients produced by metabolism into chemical energy by the production of high energy molecules like ATP. The cell membrane allows the cell to maintain a fairly stable concentration of these components. This stability is called homeostatis.


DNA and RNA

All living cells contain two types of nucleic acid polimers. Deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) is the primary vehicle for storing genetic information in the cell and Ribonucleic acid (RNA) is the primary vehicle for transferring and processing information in the cell. Some of this information is used to make the hundreds or thousands of specialized proteins found in each cell and other information is used to control the operation of the cell. Each nucleic acid molecule is composed of long sequences of four different types of units called nucleotides. Each nucleotide is composed of a sugar, either ribose or deoxyribose and one of four different nucleobases. They are bound into long strands by means of phosphate bonds. The information is coded by the sequence of these different nucleobases. Every amino acid in every protein within a cell is coded by a particular sequence of three bases.


DNA and RNA are very similar except that the sugar in DNA is missing an oxygen atom and one of the nucleotides is different in RNA compared to DNA. Nevertheless, these small differences causes DNA to take the form of a stiff double stranded double helix while RNA is a flexible single stranded chain. This flexibility allows RNA to combine with protein to form complex nano-robotic multimolecular structures which are involved in transcription, translation and replication of genetic information. However, the DNA double helix is much more stable and easier to copy accurately than RNA.


complex proteins

All living cells contain complex macromolecular protein structures which are involved in metabolism (energy production), in translation, transcription and replication (information processing), in the maintenance and functioning of the cell membrane (used to maintain homeostasis) and in various forms of motility. The most complex of these are the proteins involved in information processing. Many of these are composed of a mixture of various proteins and several RNA strands. The largest and most complex of these is the ribosome, which is involved in translation, the creation of protein using information stored in DNA. Most of these protein structures function as molecular machinery with complex moving parts. The speed at which these molecules operate and move is impressive.


Essence of Life

Many biology textbooks attempt to describe living organisms by the traits which most of them exhibit. This is a phenomenological definition of life. In other words, life is that which is contained by objects which manifest the traits or phenomena on the list. However, we saw that some non-living objects share some of these traits, and some living organisms lack one or two of these traits. This shows us that there is something missing in such descriptions of a living organism. That is because a living organism is best defined as an object which contains life. This life allows it to do many unique things which only living organisms do best. However, for that we need to define what life actually is.


Historical Definitions of Life

Throughout history many philosophers and scientists have tried to define life. Some of the earliest definitions which have survived to the present were made by a Greek philosopher named Empedocles around the year 430 BC. He believed that life is the result of a precise mixture of elements. Since then various theories about the nature of life have been put forward. These theories can be grouped into three categories.


1. Materialism – this is one of the oldest view of life and holds that life is produced by the proper mixture of elements. This is the view held by Empedocles.


2. Hylomorphism – this view was developed by Aristotle around 322 BC and holds that life is produced by the existence of a proper form or design. It is this form or structural design which produces life.


3. Vitalism – This view was developed in its modern form by Stahl in the 17th century. It held that life is in essence immaterial. Some popular descriptions of vitalism see life as an immaterial fluid, a force or an energy field. The force in the Star Wars double movie multi trilogy appears to be based loosely on the concept of vitalism. In the Star Trek series they have technology which is able to detect life signs. This also assumes that life is some sort of substance that can be detected by instruments. Even though these are works of fiction, it shows that many people tend to define life using a vitalistic point of view.


Most modern biologists would state that these ancient theories have been discredited, at least in their original form, although they each might hold an element of truth. Scientific progress in the last century has allowed us to understand more accurately the structure and function of the cell, the smallest unit of life. In spite of this, there is no general agreement about the definition of life. However, there is one definition which seems to explain many aspects of life.


A Possible definition of life

As scientist were able to explore the ever smaller structures within the cell they came across something which sets living cells apart from all other material objects. This is the existence of a complex molecule called DNA which stores enormous quantities of information, and the existence of complex structures within the cell which allows this information to control all the activity of the cell. No other naturally occurring object contains discretely encoded information. Therefore, information must be an essential component of life. Using this fact and some of the behavioral traits described above, we can suggest a tentative definition of life and examine it logically to see how well it stands up to scrutiny.


A possible definition of life – Life has something to do with the integration of information and energy. In other words, energized information is an important, if not the essential, component of life.


Another definition of life – Life is the control of energy and matter by information.


This definition has the advantage of being based on two things that are measurable. We can measure the amount of energy an organism consumes, and we can measure the amount of information contained in the genetic material of the cells of the organism. It also implies a definition for living organisms.


A living organism is a physical object which integrates information and energy.


This allows us to recognize other forms of life which might not be chemical. For example, when can we consider a robot to be alive? If a robot is alive, is this life like that contained in a plant, in an animal or in a human being? This is important to determine because we confer very few rights to plants, a few basic rights to higher animals but recognize that humans have fundamental unalienable rights. This also leads us to the possibility tha organisms are alive at different levels. For example, the body of a person who is brain dead still has a measure of life. At the other end of life, at the beginning, is there a difference between the life contained by a fertilized human egg or blastula and a third trimester fetus? We will examine this briefly in the next section.


Levels of Life

Living organisms process information at various different levels. The way an organism processes information is useful as a way to categorize organisms.


Bios (life)

All living creatures process information at the molecular level using complex molecules composed of protein and RNA to process the information stored in DNA.


The Greek term for life is ‘bios.’ This is the level that uses DNA, RNA, ribosomes and other protein macromolecules to process information. This is the DNA-RNA-protein form of life.


Anima (soul)

Animals process information at the cellular level using specialized cells called nerves to process the information stored in the brain.


Some organisms have a nervous system where specialized thread-like cells transmit information quickly using electrical signals. We call these organisms ‘animals’ and call non-animals ‘plants’, or ‘plant-like’ organisms. Animals are able to process and use information much more quickly and efficiently than plants. Furthermore, nerve based information systems have a great ability to acquire vast quantities of information from their environment fairly quickly, something which DNA-RNA-protein life is not able to do. Ancients called this ability to process and use information ‘anima’ and called the system which processes this information a ‘soul’.


Sentience (spirit)

Humans are able to process complex abstract symbolic information, to communicate it to other humans and to store it outside of themselves in ways that later generations can access it.


There is one animal which is able to process and communicate abstract information using symbolic language. This animal is the human being, which, of course, includes you and me. We are not sure how or why we are able to process information this way. However, it distinguishes us from all other living physical organisms. We call the processing of abstract information ‘thought’ or ‘thinking’ and the ability to think is called ‘sentience.’ As far as we know, humans are the only physical living organisms that can think. Some people call whatever it is that allows us to think the ‘spirit’.


Hierarchy of life

This creates a hierarchy of life. All living creatures posses ‘bios’ or life, animals posses ‘anima’, or a soul, and humans, the highest living creatures, posses ‘sentience,’ or a spirit.


origin of life


The Nature of the Question

The origin of life, and, especially, the origin of the human species has been one of the most important questions which people have asked for as long as we have records. The question has been tackled by religion, philosophy and science and its answer impacts other fundamental questions such as the existence of God and the existence of an afterlife. These, in turn, impact questions such as the definition of morality and ethics. Therefore, the answer to the question of the origin of life impacts our behavior. This creates strong biases which we must consider when we look to answer this question. When the conclusion of deductive logic does not seem to be true, it is then logically necessary to deny one or both of the premises. However, one must be careful that one does not deny the premises simply because one does not like the conclusion.


the irreducibility of life

As modern science studies living organisms in more detailed it has discovered the tremendous complexity of even the simplest living organisms. In some ways this has made it more difficult to find a natural explanation for the origin of life. Our study of living organisms has shown that life is irreducible. This means that life must have a minimum complexity. It does not seem possible for extremely simple life forms to exist. This means that there is a large gap between non-living minerals and living organisms. New discoveries have not made the gap smaller but have simply defined the gap more precisely.


We saw that life is the control of matter and energy by information or the integration of information and energy by complex physical objects. In order for life to exist there must exist information, there must exist molecular machinery which allows this information to be stored and used and the informational blueprint for making, maintaining and running these complex molecules must be stored in that information system. We saw that the smallest organisms in existence today consist of a cell, DNA, RNA, ribosomes and a host of other complex protein molecules involved in controlling translation, transcription, replication, metabolism, and in maintaining the structure of the cell and homeostasis. All these things must be in place and functioning properly for life to exist.


Even if all we want the organism to do is to replicate there needs to be a complex system in place. Replication is dependent on translation because replication is performed by complex proteins. Therefore, there needs to be a system in place to perform translation and transcription in order to create these proteins. The information to create all these proteins must be stored in DNA or a precursor. In all known life forms the structure responsible for protein synthesis is the ribosome. The amount of information contained in the ribosome alone in modern bacteria is the equivalent of 30,331 base pairs. This is 11997 for the large subunit proteins, 9384 for small subunit proteins, 7470 in rRNA and 1480 in tRNA. The RNA polymerase, which produces messenger RNA from DNA templates, contains 6 protein subunits which have the information content of 12,333 base pairs. These are just two of many protein assemblages involved in the most basic functions of life. This does not include molecular machinery necessary for metabolism and homeostasis. How this complex system first came into existence is one of the fundamental questions of our reality.


RNA World

The most widely accepted possible precursor to life are self replicating systems of RNA chains. RNA has properties in some ways intermediate between DNA and proteins. It can store information and at the same time is flexible enough to form simple enzymes called ribozymes. It is postulated that chains of RNA formed which could catalyze specific steps in RNA replication and formed rudimentary self-replicating systems which evolved into the DNA, RNA, protein systems we have today. Experiments have shown the ability of RNA ribozymes to catalyze their own formation from preparations containing short strands of RNA. It must be noted, however, that these strands were actually already quite long and complex and the truly difficult step is the formation of such strands in the first place.


Even though this view is held widely, it has many difficulties. The first difficulty is that the synthesis of the nucleic bases, especially the ones based on pyrimidine is quite difficult and the product is relatively unstable. For example, the nucleoside cytosine has a half-life in isolation of 19 days at 100 °C (212 °F) and 17,000 years in freezing water. Furthermore, each nucleotide base has two sites which are used for the phosphate bond. In order to form chains of RNA the hydroxyl (OH) oxygen at the third carbon must bind to the phosphate bound to the oxygen at the fifth carbon atom. This is called 3' to 5' linkage. However, solutions of nucleosides and activated phosphorus will just as easily form 5' to 5' and 3' to 3' linkages. Furthermore, linkages can occur in the exocyclic amino group of the two ring nucleic bases adenine, cytosine, and guanine. The ribose sugar in RNA also has a hydroxyl oxygen at the second carbon, 2', which can form a phosphate bond. This is one of the main differences with DNA because the sugar deoxyribose is missing that particular oxygen which eliminates one source of binding error. Consequently, the nucleotide has three or four binding sites but only two are used, and they must be used in the correct order. Furthermore, so far, the mechanisms postulated for the prebiotic formation of d-ribose produce a mixture of many sugars, including l-ribose and no mechanism for extracting pure d-ribose has been described. These are simply a few examples of the problems faced by the production of RNA by natural means. Many other steps are involved and most of them face significant problems.


Not only is it difficult to synthesize RNA, once formed it is also much more unstable than DNA because of the hydroxyl group at the 2' carbon. This presence of this oxygen has two consequences. First of all, it can bind to the phosphate bound to the oxygen at the 3' carbon. This causes the bond with the 5' carbon of the following nucleotide to be broken. This ruptures the chain at that point. Furthermore, the 2' hydroxyl group makes the RNA molecule much more flexible. This flexibility is useful in incorporating RNA into the complex protein structures found in the ribosomes. However, in solution this allows the strand to loop and when the two strands cross it brings free binding sites into close proximity to phosphate bonds allowing the chain to break and re-link at the crossing point. This obviously scrambles the information found in the chain. This makes RNA fairly unstable even in laboratory conditions. The reactivity which makes it a better enzyme than DNA also makes it much more unstable than DNA and basically unsuitable as a storage deposit for information.


Another problem with the RNA world is that even though RNA shares functions with both DNA and protein in that it can store information and also serve as a catalyst, it is not very good at either. We saw that RNA is not stable, and copying RNA is much more difficult than copying DNA because it does not form a stable double helix. A second RNA strand must be formed from the first and then that strand must be copied again. Furthermore, the catalytic properties of RNA are limited. The utility of RNA lies in serving as an intermediary in the transfer of information between DNA and proteins. This is the role which it plays in all known living organisms. An organism composed purely of RNA would be fragile and inefficient even in theory.


A final problem with the RNA world theory is that even with all the technology and information which we have at our disposal, nobody has ever been able to create an RNA organism which can replicate in a soup of nucleotides even under ideal controlled laboratory conditions. This is true even when we have a known solution to the problem of transcritption, translation and replication in the form of modern living organisms. If organisms composed of RNA were possible, one would think that we could reverse engineer them from what we have now. However, this has not occurred. If someone could create such a self replicating system it would go a long way towards showing that the RNA world is a likely precursor to the modern form of life.


Alternate hypotheses

Other Types of Nucleic Acids


Because of difficulties with the RNA world, some have postulated that other types of nucleic acid chains were the precursors to the present system. Peptide nucleic acid (PAN), threose nucleic acid (TNA) and glycol nucleic acid (GNA) have been artificially synthesized and have been suggested as possible precursors. However, their prebiotic synthesis faces many of the same objections as those which apply to the prebiotic synthesis of RNA.


Panspermia


Some have speculated that RNA was indeed the precursor but that the origin of life occurred on another planet that was more favorable to the origination of life than the early earth. Early life-forms in the form of bacteria or spores were then accidentally or deliberately transported to Earth. Accidental transportation may have taken the form of a large meteoritic impact which scattered bacteria containing debris throughout the galaxy to be deposited on Earth by meteorites. This theory is purely speculative since no alien life forms have been isolated from meteorites. Claims to have found bacteria inside meteorites have yielded slightly different strains of common terrestrial bacteria making it likely that the bacteria were contaminants from Earth.


intelligent design

The absence of a plausible natural scenario for the origin of life leaves open only two possibilities. (A) A natural explanation exists but we have not yet discovered it (probably because it is more complicated than we expect) or (B) life has a supernatural origin. This later option means that life was designed and created by an intelligence which operates outside of the time-space universe which we know. Indeed, the mystery of the origin of life is probably one of the strongest evidences for the existence of God, alongside the question of the origin of the universe itself. Both positions (A) and (B) take faith. The first position places faith in some unknown future discovery while the second position focuses on evidence as it actually exists at the present.


The creation of artificial, simple, stable, self replicating chemical systems which are able to store information and reproduce would lend much weight to the natural formation of life. However, every year that passes without such a feat makes it more likely that a self replicating system simpler than the DNA-RNA-protein system which currently exists is simply not possible. The complexity of this system makes it highly unlikely that it arose by chance and points to a supernatural origin for the system. If the origin of life was the result of supernatural intervention this leaves open the possibility that other aspects of the story of life are also the result of the intervention of this supernatural intelligence.


Keywords

life


See Also

Living Organisms
Dna
Rna
Mitochondria
Vitalism

References

Bibliography

top

to here7